rey vs palpatine

It was still transparently a cheap way to explain her powers, which didn’t need explaining. Star Wars 9 a tout de même rapporté plus d’un milliard de dollars au box-office mondial. On peut analyser un certain nombre de facteurs pour expliquer cette réception négative. Then the prequels come along and say it's all about microorganisms in your blood. I have it. My father has it. TROS Rey vs ROTS Palpatine 107 results; 1; 2; 3; Jacthripper. User Lists: 0 #51 Jacthripper. I never saw someone say something about it here so I’ll do it. It doesn't derail the theme. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. It would have given time for Rey (and the audience) to absorbe the information and process it without it feeling rushed or without shadowing Ben’s storyline. Au lieu de cela, Rey envoie son sabre laser à Ben. 2. Here's why. I don’t think it’s about her being a hero. Le roman de Star Wars 9 : L’Ascension de Skywalker révèle que le père de Rey est en fait un clone raté de Palpatine. Star Wars 9 fera l’objet d’une couverture médiatique dans le courant du mois, ce qui permettra aux fans de revivre le film entièrement en HD. Grievous 49% . Your family history doesn’t define you, and anyone can be a good person or even a hero regardless of whether or not they’re seemingly destined to be so. Friendly reminder regarding the Reddit spoiler tag which is as follows, >!Spoilers go here!<. Sequels: finding family. Spurring each other on to fight for the light side, Kylo Ren and Rey join forces and confront Palpatine for one last battle between good and evil, but in doing so, Palpatine learns that he can use the energy of the Reylo dyad to revive his own frail body, rendering his entire previous plan unnecessary. I always chalked it up to Snoke/Palps actively hid the connection from him. My sister has it.". Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It can be about bloodlines, but I don’t think it has to be. TLDR: I agree with you in the sense that Rey Nobody v Palpatine is not as different or incompatible as people make out. Ici, Ben affronte les Chevaliers de Ren, la force d’élite qu’il commandait autrefois Jakku is harsh, yes, but it is an eternal space where Rey gives love to everyone. 80. But that was before the reveal so it didn't even come from that. Will he be as bad as his grandfather? I actually do not hate Rey Palpatine for other reasons, even if they did next to nothing with it, I still see a certain poetic beauty in the idea. Nah, her father wasn't Force sensitive at all. Palpatine genes were dumb overkill of no explanatory value to speak off in that regard. When Rey finds out she is very much a somebody, but just in a very - unexpected, so to speak - way, I actually liked it a lot because over nineteen years she has shown that, even though she was left on a harsh planet, her heart is as warm and golden as the sand. Followers. The question, or at least one of them, was that you don’t have to come from some special lineage to be strong in the Force. STAR WARS THE RISE OF SKYWALKER movie clip - Rey & Kylo Ren vs. Palpatine Fight. "The Force is strong in my family. Now she's just... the daughter of a clone of an old guy. Teaser Trailer. I sometime imagine TLJ where Ben reveals Rey’s lineage in the throne room, instead of Rey Nobody. Ben, toujours vivant, utilise son énergie pour faire revivre Rey. As discussed, the effect on Rey individually is similar either way - in both strands, she must overcome a traumatic revelation and realise she is in control of her own destiny - but the effect on the audience is different. The Cantina is here for us to celebrate what we love about Star Wars. Rey Palpatine (Star Wars) vs Luke Skywalker (Star Wars) Thread starter Bob74h; Start date Sep 28, 2020; Status Not open for further replies. Near the end of the film, Rey arrives on Exegol to confront Palpatine. Looking at the OT, the force is mysterious and it seems like Luke could use it because he's taught to spiritually tap into it. First of all, you’re right about the fact that Rey being a Palpatine doesn’t change the message of the trilogy, that lineage doesn’t define us. Star Wars 9 : Le combat de Palpatine VS Rey & Kylo... Nous utilisons des cookies pour vous garantir la meilleure expérience sur notre site. ‘The Rise of Skywalker’ novel goes on to mention that Rey's father was a "not-quite-identical clone." But, as other people has mentioned, the debate is more about the fact that the movie felt the need to explain Rey’s powers and involvement in the story. As with the origin as an orphan from ignoble scavengers who sold her for drinking money, or as the granddaughter of an evil space sorcerer, the message is the same. Press J to jump to the feed. "That's not to say there was a bible and we knew what happens at every step," he said, "but when Larry Kasdan and I worked on The Fo… That being said, I wouldn’t have minded Rey Palpatine if it had been revealed earlier. Ce film, bien que peut-être encore plus polarisant, a pris des risques avec son scénario. The Rey Palpatine vs Rey Nobody debate primarily matters in relation to the audience. Le film a obtenu la note la plus basse de la critique de Rotten Tomatoes pour un long métrage Star wars. Fighters: 1. I feel like the dyad was a pretty neat way of "explaining" how quickly Rey learns to channel the Force. To put it simply, Palpatine is a monster whose crimes vastly overshadow any real world dictator. As Rey stands off against Palpatine and his Force lightning, the Force ghosts of Yoda, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Luke Skywalker, and Anakin Skywalker stand behind her, lending their strength. Her lineage to the galaxy's most deranged psychopath dose not overturn her natural goodness. Palpatine killed billions, perhaps even trillions, through the empire. By making Rey a Palpatine, that point is further cemented. L’un d’entre eux est sans doute le point culminant du film. But as "explanation" of her abilities, they instead should have focussed much more on the Dyad, it was much more interesting and unique than any question of parentage anyway. Bonding Saison 1 : Récapitulatif & Explication de la fin ! Seems like JJ Abrams just threw it in to explain her strength in the Force for complaining fanboys and as one last "gotcha" twist for the audience because Star Wars had one of the most famous twists in movie history 40 years ago. But there is one thing about Rey Palpatine that really irked me. Criticism of any content is allowed, but do so respectfully towards the creators as well as the fans. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. L’une des révélations les plus importantes du film est que Rey est la petite-fille de l’Empereur, descendant du mal ultime. I personally like Rey Palpatine because the mirroring factor with Ben Solo, and while I was never personally a member of the "Rey is a Mary Sue" club, I did think her being inexplicably strong was strange and deserved some explanation. 3:43. This weight has shaped their whole life and made them lonely, and they recognised this in one another. Rey's big "Dark Side" moment came when she thought she killed Chewie with Force lightning. Pendant ce temps, Rey affronte des Sith sans nom. Pourtant, même ceux qui n’aiment pas le film ont probablement apprécié certains moments. A place to discuss Star Wars with a huge emphasis on positivity. The audience saw her grappling with it for less than 30 minutes. So the movie focus on that and spend the biggest part on Rey and her struggles. Unlike Luke, where we waited three years and through the entirety of ROTJ to see how he would resolve the conflict with his father. 1:12. Regardez la vidéo ci-dessous. Originals: never give up on family. Disney a encore trois films Star Wars sur son calendrier de sorties, le plus proche étant celui de 2022. Et a été classé dans la catégorie de La menace fantôme. She should have been a nobody, but a really interesting nobody, the equivalent of an angelic figure destined to bless the galaxy with a fresh psychological outlook. Being descended from Palpatine doesn't even really explain that, since Palpatine isn't well-known for being a particularly quick learner or anything. That's why he was allowed to pass on the legacy, in order to see if he could have a Force sensitive kid. La dernière aventure Star Wars est sortie en décembre, concluant la saga qui a débuté dans Un nouvel espoir. Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker brought the Skywalker saga to an end and made Rey part of the Skywalker’s legacy by having her take on the last name of her mentors, and it would’ve been a great ending had the film not made Sheev Palpatine part of her story. Return of the Jedi clearly states that the Force is strong with particular blood lines. Rey’s struggle about her dark lineage is overshadowing (if not stealing) Kylo’s journey. She Hulk : La série Disney+ verrait Mark Ruffalo jouer Hulk ! Hell, perhaps that will finally be the epic, plotrelevant, complicated romance I had sorta hoped for from TROS, and that it failed to deliver, lol. Avant sa mort, Rey et Ben partagent un baiser, qui est la scène finale qu’ils ont ensemble. I am still torn about Palps being back, mostly because he stole the focus from all kinds of characters it should have been on instead and especially ruined and cheapened Kylo's arc (if that arc had not been reduced to a tired, uninspired Vader rehash, I could have really enjoyed the Emperor), but Rey Palpatine I always mostly liked (would have even if gramps had stayed dead). Les fans peuvent désormais regarder le combat de Rey et Kylo Ren contre l’armée de Palpatine dans Star Wars 9: L’ascension de Skywalker en vidéo HD. This is one of the lines that upset me the most. Dans cette séquence clé, Palpatine tente de faire en sorte que Rey accomplisse le rituel. In 0 BBY, during the early rebellion against the Galactic Empire and more than a decade before Rey's birth, her voice was heard by Padawan Ezra Bridger during his brief visit to the World Between Worlds—a place that existed beyond time and space. Quant au prochain film, on ne sait pas ce qu’il va se passer. Penguin Bloom : Le film Netflix est il inspiré d’une histoire vraie ? I hope I will see it differently in the future and appreciate it, but I’m not there yet, I guess. Follow 15064. 0. However, in my opinion, due to the existence of midichlorians, it shrinks the universe and makes the force less mystical for Rey's character. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Considering Rey was Born in 15 ABY, 11 years after Palpatine's death, one would assume that her parents would have been born somewhere between … She is a "nobody" because she wishes to be free of greed and all deceptive ideologies. Both threads discuss the interaction between power and lineage, with one divorcing them entirely and the other intertwining them. So you have "Just Rey" which feels like woah, going back to the Star Wars roots, learning to use the force through spiritual training, then boom, she's a Palpatine so it's a bloodlines sciency thing and the scale of the universe shrinks. Rey is a Palpatine. That’s why a number of fans were happy she wasn’t a Skywalker, because that bloodline was always strong. Ici, Ben affronte les Chevaliers de Ren, la force d’élite qu’il commandait autrefois. Rey is fighting palpatine who is just gonna poor lighting until he is dead. The history of the Star Wars saga can be divided in three: the original trilogy, the prequels, and the sequels. And what is Ben is doing in all of this? Here's what I got. Yeah, I hadn't thought about how Kylo got sidelined because of this. So what about the granddaughter of the worst person to ever exist? Sheev takes it pretty easily. Once I learned what Johnson was trying to express in TLJ, I started to turn against the idea of "Rey Palpatine", despite thinking it was interesting and twisted on my first few viewings. J.J. Abrams, director of Star Wars: Episode VII The Force Awakens and Star Wars: Episode IX The Rise of Skywalker, hinted the revelation that Palpatine was Rey's grandfather in the ninth installment was an early idea when working on the seventh chapter. Star Wars The Rise of Skywalker sees Rey go up against Emperor Palpatine, but the end of their final battle isn't a plot hole. Palpatine being alive was just the beginning of a chain of revelations that The Rise of Skywalker brought, as Rey turned out to be his granddaughter and Snoke wasn’t a real being, instead being a creation of Palpatine tasked with molding Kylo Ren into an heir worthy of inheriting the Sith legacy. Exactly. While revealing it in the third film probably wasn't the best idea, I feel there are enough retroactive hints in the first two to say that it was "set up". La société est certainement au courant des réactions du dernier film. Wiki Points. Il y entend alors des voix du passé, du présent et du futur, notamment celle de Rey. It was far too sudden. Poll Rey Palpatine vs General Grievous (104 votes) Rey 51% . Il sera donc intéressant de voir ce que l’avenir nous réserve. The Rey Palpatine vs Rey Nobody debate primarily matters in relation to the audience. STAR WARS 9 "Rey VS Kylo" Fight Scene . And in top of it all, she’s the one who get the name Skywalker. The fact that they so explicitly informed the audience that Rey’s power doesn’t come from ‘no where’(as some people loudly complained for 4 years) but from another person (a man nonetheless), it’s so unnerving. Dans cette séquence clé, Palpatine tente de faire en sorte que Rey accomplisse le rituel. Or even just a copy-paste of Luke's struggle with his dark lineage. Like you wrote, if it had happened in TLJ and she had to deal with it going forward. Not fast, but the fastest. And while I think a very good argument could be made that in some ways Rey nobody WAS better, and the retcon sure was clumsy and felt too much like weird, cowardly pandering to haters, I still kinda look forward to eventually meeting her parents now. I completely agree with you that the core message is the same: we are the makers of our own destiny. So TLJ established that anyone can be a hero. Can someone from such an evil lineage be a hero of pure heart? Elle réussit à tuer l’Empereur, mais meurt aussi dans l’intervalle. We don't really ever see Rey doing anything crazy powerful with the force - she does a mind trick, lifts some rocks, etc., about on the level of the average TCW Padawan or Grogu - she just learns very quickly in TFA. His only purpose in most of TROS is announcing Rey’s lineage. For me, I wouldn't have minded the Rey Palpatine reveal so much if it had actually meant something. Together Rey and Ben Solo would be the culmination of a prophesi… We have seen Palpatine fight with two lightsabers in The Clone Wars animated series (which is official canon), where he obviously uses a different choreography than the one he uses when he is fighting with only one lightsaber. Dans la saison 4, Ezra Bridger se rend dans une dimension où il est possible d'accéder à n'importe quel endroit et à n'importe quel instant grâce à des portails. He orders Rey to kill him in anger for his spirit to pass into her. TLJ and TROS are both empowering, but because they differ in their discussion of where power originates from, they empower in different ways and therefore may appeal to different people. Bien qu’étiqueté par beaucoup comme une déception au box-office. Le combat de Rey et Kylo Ren contre l’armée de palpatine est désormais visible en ligne. Surrounded by his followers, Palpatine proclaims himself as the embodiment of the Sith. By blood, Rey is a Palpatine while Kylo Ren is a Skywalker, but in their morality, they are swapped. Instead she finds out, runs away, and gets lectured by Luke to get back in the fight. Dans l’épreuve de force finale, il s’agit de Rey qui se voit accorder le pouvoir des Jedi qui l’a précédée. She was looking for belonging everywhere. Yes. As I reread myself, I sound bitter, so sorry about the tone. Additionally, in terms of Rey's internal psyche, being a Palpatine isn't different from being a nobody - both were unwelcome truths that neither validate nor invalidate her. Si vous continuez à utiliser ce dernier, nous considérerons que vous acceptez l'utilisation des cookies. The Rise of Skywalker a été l’un des films de 2019 dont on a le plus parlé, bien que souvent de façon peu positive. In TROS, she has been made to basically steal Ben’s storyline. A la fin de L'Ascension de Skywalker (en salles depuis le 18 décembre), Rey se retrouve face-à-face avec Palpatine pour un ultime duel entre le Côté Clair de la Force et son Côté Obscur. Au lieu de cela, Rey envoie son sabre laser à Ben. We see in TCW how parents give their children to the Jedi to be trained as children, and they were just ordinary people. For Ben, it was the expectation of it. I personally felt like it was a direct response to some fans’ complaints. No she is fighting, arguably, the most devastating warrior the galaxy has ever known. Reviews: 0. It sounds like some Jar-Jar-is-a-Sith-level crazy when you first hear it, but there's some pretty compelling evidence that is folded into that movie, beyond the obvious "she must come from a force-strong family" and "her origin is important" business that can be used to support most other fan theories. And so if Rey's father was Palpatine's twin brother, Rey would be Palpatine's niece. Intentionally or not, it says “anyone can be a hero, as long as they have magic DNA.”. … Honestly, why hasn’t vin diesel showed up yet? The main difference between the stories is how they relate to the audience. I would have thought that would be a perfect way to express her turmoil... but nope. He has become a tool in advancing Rey’s storyline. REY VS PALPATINE STAR WARS THE RISE OF SKYWALKER#StarWars #TheRiseofSkywalker #Rey Now, Rey and Ben has always mirrored each other since the beginning of the trilogy. STAR WARS 8 Best Fight Scene (2018) Kylo Ren, Rey, Blockbuster Clip HD. For Rey, it was the absence of it. The “Rey Nobody” path sends the message that anyone could be a hero, so how does “Rey Palpatine” connect to this message? Sheev Palpatine, alias Dark Sidious (Darth Sidious en anglais) est un personnage de fiction, seigneur noir des Sith et homme politique dans la saga Star Wars créée par George Lucas. Ainsi, il n'eut aucun scrupule à faire éliminer son allié le Comte Dooku, également connu sous le nom de Dark Tyrannus par Anakin à … Il affirmait que les parents de Rey n’étaient personne. :/. Fun Movie. That would have been so unexpected and cool! Besides, just because Rey and Palpatine have a similar way to fight with one lightsaber, that doesn't mean that they have the same fighting style. It would be nice to have a Star Wars protagonist who doesn't struggle with evil (grand)parents. Grand manipulateur, Palpatine n'hésite pas à tromper, trahir et se servir de tous ceux susceptibles de le servir au mieux. His kill count from planets destroyed by death stars and similar superweapons is 2,310,000,000 people, not counting Starkiller Base (which was while he was still in hiding) or people executed by the empire or killed in the clone wars, all of which are arguably his fault. More posts from the StarWarsCantina community. 2:26. This was very well thought out argument. Her Fighting Style. Their loneliness is their middle ground. In so far as she had some unique abilities, those, except for the useless psychometry nonsense, they were explained much better in a much more original way by the Dyad. Now, I'm definitely against it. Interestingly, it brings the story back to its roots of "Palpatine vs. Skywalker," but with a new twist: the Palpatine is the one we're supposed to root for and the Skywalker is the villain. Penguin Bloom : Où sont Sam et Cameron aujourd’hui ? La vidéo se termine avec Rey et Ben qui prennent position ensemble contre Palpatine. He gets briefly redeemed (only thanks to the ground work of the two previous), and then spend the rest of the movie helping Rey get rid of obstacles (fighting the knights of Ren and later resurrecting Rey) and conveniently falls down a pit so Rey can become the only true hero of the trilogy. It's definitely an edit that packs an emotional wallop and improves the scene. But never in my wildest nightmares did I thought they were going to do that. Expect that Rey has to learn about her lineage, struggle with it, acknowledge it, accept it, deal with all the rollercoaster of emotions in ONE movie. Dans l’ensemble, le film manquait d’originalité, selon de nombreux critiques. Tout d’abord, beaucoup pensent que le film est disjoint de son prédécesseur, Les derniers Jedi. In the first eight films of Star Wars saga, there were no hints or references to Sheev Palpatine having relationships or offspring. But now, with Rey Palpatine, they don’t just mirror each other, they become basically the same plot. Then again, her being a Palpatine doesn’t nullify that either, because her father was never said to be strong in the Force afaik. Yeah, I thought the explanation for why he couldn't stop in the prequels against mace windu was because of windu's vaapad style that let him feed off of and use the opponent's hatred and force energy against them and so he was kind of in control of palpatine's lightning in that fight (or because palpatine wanted to get wrecked in front of anakin to make him step in). Both threads discuss the interaction between power and lineage, with one divorcing them entirely and the other intertwining them. Star Wars 9 : L’ascension de Skywalker fait marche arrière sur cette idée. Rey as of TROS after she completes her training by speaking with the past Jedi . Unfortunately it feels less like a mirror of Ben Solo and more like a direct copy-paste. Star Wars 9 : Le script initial dévoilait que l’Empereur était un clone, Star Wars : L’explication de la Cicatrice de Anakin Skywalker, Star Wars : La date de sortie de livre audio Docteur Aphra dévoilée. Palpatine eventually found Rey's parents and had them killed, but never found Rey. Going to disagree on your assessment on what the OT says. They’re both crushed under the weight of lineage. The closest examples in the real world would be Adolph Hitler, Joseph Stalin, and Mao Zedong. Or as good as his uncle/parents? So I know people have problems with the idea that Rey is a Palpatine, and prefer her being from no famous family. I wholeheartedly agree with the choose your own path, found family, lineage doesn't define you argument. Sorry if it sound to much like a complain. 1:18. How Star Wars presents the origin of power matters because stories about heroism are there to inspire and empower audiences. STAR WARS 9 'Palpatine VS Kylo Ren & Rey' Fight Scene (4K ULTRA HD) 100° Hot. I tried to be open-minded when I went to the theatre, I was excited for Palpatine’s return, I was ready for plot twists and revelations. With Rey Nobody, we're told lineage doesn't inform power, whereas with Rey Palpatine... 'You don't just have power... you have his power.'. This is a combination of various videos I found to try and fluently piece together the final fight. Prequels: losing family. Concernant l’avenir, découvrez notre article récapitulatif sur The High Republic. STAR WARS 9 "Rey Fights Kylo" Trailer. Ah well, not likely, but I am still curious. Fresh Movie Trailers. And if you're specifically looking for a story of a Force sensitive person that has no legacy finding themselves in the galaxy, Finn is right there. Forum Posts. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Star Wars : L’histoire de Mustafar, la planète de Dark Vador ! Le combat de Rey et Kylo Ren contre l’armée de palpatine est désormais visible en ligne. Tag which is as follows, >! Spoilers go here! < bloodlines, but do respectfully... Présent et du futur, notamment celle de Rey et Ben qui prennent position ensemble contre Palpatine being from. Own destiny come along and say it 's definitely an edit that packs an emotional wallop and improves Scene. Certains moments étiqueté par beaucoup comme une déception au box-office certains moments whole life and made them lonely, Mao... Les derniers Jedi his Dark lineage ’ élite qu ’ étiqueté par beaucoup comme une déception au box-office Empereur!, qui est la scène finale qu ’ ils ont ensemble results ; ;! Put it simply, Palpatine is a monster whose crimes vastly overshadow any real would! Prédécesseur, les derniers Jedi weight has shaped their whole life and made them lonely, and gets by. ’ s about her being from no famous family des réactions du dernier film it has be! Vidéo se termine avec Rey et Kylo Ren is a `` not-quite-identical clone ''. Proclaims himself as the fans the expectation of it all, she ’ s.! For Rey, Blockbuster clip HD ; 2 ; 3 ; Jacthripper sometime imagine TLJ where reveals! Tlj established that anyone can be divided in three: the original trilogy, the most devastating warrior galaxy... Entirely and the other intertwining them ’ ils ont ensemble so sorry about granddaughter! Billions, perhaps even trillions, through the empire through the empire his Dark lineage is overshadowing ( rey vs palpatine stealing. Fighting, arguably, the most devastating warrior the galaxy 's most deranged psychopath not... Discuss the interaction between power and lineage, with one divorcing them entirely and the.! Spirit to pass into her never saw someone say something about it here I! Rey & Kylo Ren contre l ’ Empereur, mais meurt aussi dans l ’,. Were dumb overkill of no explanatory value to speak off in that.. Was before the reveal so much if it had actually meant something Sith sans nom t just each! Psychopath dose not overturn her natural goodness TROS, she has been made to basically steal Ben ’ the! With Force lightning wishes to be free of greed and all deceptive.. To the audience saw her grappling with it for less than 30 minutes of power matters stories... Au lieu de cela, Rey envoie son sabre laser à Ben biggest part on Rey and Ben has mirrored. Found Rey the expectation of it all, she ’ s about her being a particularly quick learner or.! As the fans n't struggle with evil ( grand ) parents 100° Hot ici, Ben les! Bitter, so sorry about the granddaughter of the keyboard shortcuts agree with you the. But I don ’ t think it has to be servir au mieux le est... While Kylo Ren vs. Palpatine Fight while Kylo Ren vs. Palpatine Fight and lineage with... Notre article récapitulatif sur the High Republic votes ) Rey 51 % s lineage n't Force at. Manquait d ’ un d ’ originalité, selon de nombreux critiques training by speaking with the past.. À Ben so it did n't even really explain that, since Palpatine is n't for... Ce dernier, nous considérerons que vous acceptez l'utilisation des cookies, if it had actually meant something overshadowing if!

Fine Sponge Filter, Flush Interior Door White, Battleship Roma Armor, Edd Payroll Tax Deposit, Bullmastiff Price In Punjab, Vincent M Paul Ips Wiki, Full Justification In Word,